Home
Prologue
Chronology
 
Sopranos
Mezzos
Altos
Tenors
Baritones
Basses
 
Conductors
Singers fr.abroad
Belgian singers
 
DD Records cd's Order CD's
 
Compilation cd's
The high C
Reactions
Sources
Links
 

mail
 
pen This page is reserved for your reactions, mild comment and welcome suggestions to Joop Lindeijer. mail


12-11-2006
Dear Sir,
I happened upon your website last night when I was researching the highest note ever sung (boy was I disappointed to hear that the top 3 titles went to two pop singers and a guy!). Anyway, I was listening to Marian Andersons "Der Tod und das Madchen" and was listening for her G#. The lowest note I heard was a c# below middle c just above 110 hz. Can you tell me where in the her low G# is?
Thank you,
April Blau

Dear April Blau,

I cannot be more specific then I already wrote:
" ... Marian Anderson sings as last line " ... sollst sanft in meinen Armen schlafen ... " During schlafen she sings a G# (103hz) (Great octave)..."

No thanks,
Joop Lindeijer


24-10-2006
dear joop lindeijer,
I hope you can help me.my english is not good enough,but this is not the real problem.i am looking for people,who are interrestet in a rare autogramm from richard tauber on a silver cigarette-etui from 1927.please let me explain in german- ich,thomas schumann,suche seriöse liebhaber von richard tauber oder auch robert nästlberger,die an solchen original-autogrammen,eingeritzt in ein silbernes zigaretten-etui,interessiert sind.dieses etui dürfte es so nicht ein zweites mal geben.auch der bekannte schauspieler gustav jahrbeck hat neben weiteren stars der damaligen zeit(die berühmten 20iger jahre)sein autogramm eingeritzt.das etui war ein weihnachtsgeschenk von der künstlerin lisa rada (oper-theater-film) an einen verehrten regisseur im jahr 1927,so die gravur im etui.lieber joop lindeijer,können sie mir einen tip geben ,in welchem forum im internet,außer ebay oder ähnlichen auktionshäusern,ich dieses seltene zigaretten-etui, mit so berühmten unterschriften,anbieten kann.oder kennen sie vielleicht opernliebhaber,die an so etwas intereresse hätten?
in der hoffnung auf eine antwort verbleibe ich mit freundlichen grüßen,
thomas schumann 24.10.06 dresden

Hernn Schumann,

Ich werde es in Deutsch versuchen, nicht mein stärkste Seite. Wie sie schon schrieben, glaube ich auch, das E-bay das Beste ist. Aber ich glaube nicht das es viel wert ist, zehn Euro oder so es was. Schwierig der richtige Liebhaber zu finden.

herzliche Grüsse,
Joop Lindeijer


07-10-2006
Dear Joop

First of all I would like to express my warmest congratualations for the great work you have done building up this web site and puting together all these interesting pieces of sound/music/voice material. I had really good time going through it last week-end.
It is by accident I discovered your work as I was looking for information regarding our French colorature soprano Mado Robin. Preparing a technical article about masking release thanks to multichannel recording, I started to learn about how musicians, conductors, singers are coping with this phenomenon. Then going from piece of information to another one, I found interesting document on opera singers and then found Mado Robin with her extraordinary voice.
As I wanted to find in which role she could reach this contre-contre Ré I went on your web site. Many thanks for the 2 excerpts. But as I am not musician I am lost with the differents notations.
So I would like to know what is the exact notes that Mado Robin is reaching in the 2 excerpts you have selected using the French notation. Is this b3/high B corresponding to our French Si 5 knowing that in private or during rehearsal she could sing as high as Ré 6.
Do you have a document that gives the correspondace betwenn our French notation, the high "capital letter" notation, and low letter notation.

With kind regards,
Jayjay

Dear Jean-José,

I don't have a document to compare the European notation with the French notation. However, when you have a piano or keyboard, that will be helpful. My old piano reaches from A2 (27hz) to a4( 3520hz).
On the left side of the keyboard I have a white key (A2), then a black key, two white keys and then the first complete group of three black keys.
On the right side I have - from right to left! - a white key (a4), then a complete group of three black keys.
So, my piano - an old one - reaches from A2 to a4, that is about 7 octaves: (A2, B2), (C1-B1), (C-B), (c-b), (c1-b1), (c2-b2), (c3-b3), (c4-a4). The first group contains only two keys, the last group misses the b4. To be exact: 7 octaves plus one key. The green groups are complete, the two red ones are incomplete. The central key is c1, that's the white key left from two black keys.
On the high C page you see a graphics that reaches from C to b3, within the square. This covers 5 octaves: (C-B), (c-b), (c1-b1), (c2-b2), (c3-b3).

I hope this will be helpful.

warm regards,
Joop Lindeijer


10-09-2006
I was on the Georgia Brown website (the new ENGLISH one) and there is a demonstration of her hitting a G10. I just wanted to know whether you have heard it and if it is in fact a G10 that she is hitting. I was under the impression that a G10 was out of human hearing range but i heard it quite clearly actually. Here is the link to the new site if you haven't checked it out yet.

http://www.georgiabrownmusic.com.br/

Thanx and keep up the good work,
G.P

L.S.
I was amazed that anybody could hear a G10, that is about 25khz. Listening the the samples, those with the keyboard: G7 was okay, G8 nothing to hear, G9 the same and G10 I could hear clearly. But not G10, I measured f#8. Perhaps something doesn't go well with the creation of the samples?

Joop Lindeijer


08-09-2006
I have been seeking a record or CD of Richard Tauber singing "Eine Kleine Liebelei"...I have been looking for song for many years. I remember hearing it as a child over 70 years ago on a 78 RPM rcord. I think it was Odeom...?? Please help if you can. My mother was from Vienna. Robert Schcik, M.D.
69 Kristin Lane
Hauppauge, NY 11788
USA

L.S.

I found Eine kleine Liebelei only as 78-rpm record: TAUBER RICHARD, Mary/Eine kleine Liebelei, Od O4923 . Available at www.lotz-verlag.de

yours sincerely,
Joop Lindeijer


05-08-2006
Dear Joop.

Does anyone know if singer tenor Richard Tauber ever performed in a city called Breslau in Germany in the year 1933 0r 1934 .I understand that he percormed " Faust' at 48 hrs notice in Breslau? what year was that? Did he perform in Breslau at any other years? Did he ever go back to Germany to perform after he left to go to England.

Your help would be greatly appreciated.
Sincerely Rena Jackson.
Richard Tauber fan.

Dear Rena,

I don't know by head or he sang in 1933/34 in Breslau and I don't also know the year of the Faust performance. I have several biographies of him - see the page sources - and perhaps this information is written some where there.
As far as I know he never returned to Germany after the war. Read the book : "Gern hab' ich die Frauen geküsst", biography Richard Tauber, by Michael Jürgs, List Verlag, München 2000
The best book ever written about Tauber.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer
Tauber fan for many years --- see the page prologue


15-07-2006
Dear Mr. Lindeijer,

Hello. I was hoping you could help me. Are you aware of any recordings of Coenraad van Bos in solo piano, chamber, or concerto repertoire, either commercially recorded or private - even radio broadcasts that might survive.

I know he recorded as an accompanist on numerous 78s of Hugo Wolf songs, but I wondered if his artistry as a solo pianist is anywhere preserved.

Thanks for any information you can offer.

Best wishes,Joe Moore
Barcelona, Spain

Dear Mr. Moore,

For as far as I know, Coenraad Bos didn't make solo recordings. In his book 'The well tempered accompanist' he only mentioned a number of Lieder recordings. Pity, because What I read about him - written by others, among them Frieda Hempel and Gerald Moore (family?) - he was a marvelous pianist and extemporizer. He could play Rachmaninoff (style) compositions of which the composer has never heard! And in Berlin he played for years in a chamber ensemble.
So you have to do it with his many Lieder recordings.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


09-07-2006
This is to inform you that yesterday the Dutch tenor ANTON DE RIDDER died. He just had married a young Hungarian wife and planned to move to Hungary later this month.

Regards
Harald Kral, Hilden/Germany

Thank you very much for the information Harald. Meanwhile I'm also informed by his nephew.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


01-07-2006
good morning,
maybe you are interested in hearing a male soprano that can reach very very high tunes! In his webside it is written he can reach the A9 (which is recorded) and even more..
and here I attach the file dowloaded from his website!
www.nicolasedda.com
best regards Giorgio Solinas

Chiacchiera con i tuoi amici in tempo reale!

Good afternoon Giorgio,

Yes, I'm interested in this male soprano. I listened to the sound sample you send me and was really amazed. What is the end? A little bit higher and we cannot hear anymore the sounds they can produce.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer

15-07-2006
I listened and measured the sound sample: Nicola Sedda - Vocal Range Game (E1-A9) 07-07-2005.mp3 carefully and did some tests. My conclusion, he can reach high, very high, but doesn't sings an A9(a6, 14khz). First I was amazed that I still could hear 14khz - I'm 65 - but when I filtered the frequencies above 13khz, I still heard the same sound as before. Remeasuring now results in B8(b5, 8.1khz), but the measurement is not exact, the sample is a mixture of many frequency peaks. Filtering those frequencies from about 7khz to 13khz makes all quiet ...nothing to hear anymore. [ ...... ].
J.L.


19-06-2006
Firstly I would like to thank you for a wonderful site! Especially the one concerning the human vocal range. You mention Maria Callas having sung a high F. Could it be this one? http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?action=download&ufid=A5497D9F6A15A278
It is an aria from Rossinis Armida - "Per me propizio il fato", could you see if I have pitched it correctly? It is rather hard to hear I guess... I hope it would not cause any problems!

Yours sincerely

Martin Rafal

Martin, thanks for the compliments,

I checked the fragment, I never heard it before. At the end Maria started the high note as an E3 (European notation) and reached - not strong as the E3 - the F3.

Thanks very much for the tip,

warm regards,
Joop Lindeijer


16-05-2006
Firstly, I would like to congratulate Your fabulous site, especially the part of it concerning the scale and range of the human voice. There You mention Callas reaching an F in alt. Among others, You might be reffering to her Armida. I send you the following link from "yousendit" for download of the fragment (it has to be done in seven days), asking for a kind confirmation (as for the F in alt) if that would be the case. Also, Callas' vocal abilities are shown well in Proch's aria "Deh, torna mio bene". The sound is poor, but I think it is worth listening to.

Armida: http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?action=download&ufid=8730647A53CE2FAD
Proch: http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?action=download&ufid=F3A15B566F58E984

Hope it works!

Regards, Marcin Rafal

Thanks for the information Marcin,

I did not refer to the Armida fragment. There she sang an D3. The Proch variations, I never heard them before, where more interesting. Not only the height - E3 - but also the duration and strength of the notes. She was in exceptional good voice those days. About the F3, I heard that she (Callas) has reached it several times, but as far as I know there is no recording, no prove of it. The Bell-fragment is the highest I ever heard.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


1-05-2006
Hello, I originally sent you a clip of a Russian Choral work that's on your page "The High C" on Dutch Divas. That was not altogether appropriate as other basses were backing up Wichniakov on the low C. This also causes more overtones to the low note, making it harder to hear. I've found some other clips that may be more appropriate. As far as opera goes, I have this clip of Siepi hitting a low C in Meyerbeer's opera Les Hugenots.
http://www.angelfire.com/ct2/metaltabs/siepilowC.mp3
Here is russian singer Vladimir Miller hitting a low Bb in Chesnokov's "Do Not Reject Me in Time of Old Age"
http://www.angelfire.com/ct2/metaltabs/millerbflat.mp3
And lastly, Vladimir Pasuikov singing a low Ab in this chant from "Cherubic Hymn" by Chesnokov, Op. 27/5.
http://www.angelfire.com/ct2/metaltabs/pasuikovAb.mp3

The clips of Mado Robin or great, the High C page is very interesting over all, I don't know of much other places that have such as assortmant of interesting clips.

One more thing--in this recording of Marian Anderson http://www.dutchdivas.net/sound/ram-files/der_tod.ram, you say she hits an F#, but when I match the last not against the piano it is a C#. Is the F#
just a mistype, or am I hearing things?

Everett Wade

Dear Mr Wade,

Thanks for the links to the samples. I already have download them and of course listened to. My first impression ... the Wichniakof sample is for me the most impressing. Of course the singing of the other basses were of help for the overall sound, but he sang the lowest notes. More isn't lower.
Concerning Marian Anderson, you are not the first to have doubts, I once re-listen and stick to my first opinion, but I will check it again. Not comparing with my old piano, he or she stands in an other room. I let you know. But F# (93hz) it is not a mistype.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer


24-04-2006
Hi,
I have been an admirer of the tenor Jan Handerson. Can you tell me if there are any cd's or recordings he made. Once he send me a tape but that has deteriorated over the years.
Kind regards from Australia, Erica.


Hi Erica,

I will forward your e-mail to his son, meanwhile a well known baritone, singing in Germany. Perhaps he can help you.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


14-03-2006
Mr. Lindeijer,

My name is Frank Byron Clark, I am a music producer/engineer who lives in Southern California, USA. I have a request that I hope you can help me with. I met Shirley Zwerus from Haarlem, Holland, The Netherlands in 1970. In 1971 I produced a music album on her while she resided her in California. She and I stayed in touch for many years after that, however we eventually lost contact with one another. Is it any way you can help me to locate her?

Please let me know anything you can. It will be greatly appreciated.

Thank you,

Frank Clark

Mr. Clark,

The only thing I know about Shirley, was that she lives - or lived - in Spain. However, I will place your e-mail on the page 'reactions' and 'reacties'. Very often people react positive to this well read part of my site. So, let's wait.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer


27-02-2006
Hello to everybody.

I am a big fan of Maria Callas and would like to make a correction. Somebody wrote that Maria Callas' highest note is "E6". Her highest note is actually "F6" and it is recorded in aria "Per me propizio il fato" from Armida in 1952.

Thank you very much,

Tair Leake

P.S. Thank you very much, Joop Lindeijer, for your wonderful site. There are so many interesting and rare things that can be found here.

Hi Tair Leake,

Somebody - Joop Lindeijer - wrote a firm e3-sharp as Callas highest note on record. I have a recording of an Armida recording - RAI- by Callas from 1952, but cannot hear a f3. By the way, I'm also a big fan of her, have almost all her records and read/have about 15 biographies of her.
She is not on my site because there is written enough about her.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer

Meanwhile (June), I received a recording of another Armida aria: "Per me propizio il fato", with a F3 sung by Callas. This aria will of course placed on the High C page.


27-02-2006
Hi :)

My name is David Crowe Holmberg. I'm a classical singer from Denmark. I'm very interested in finding any recordings with dutch soprano Rina Cornelissens. So far I have had no luck and I hope you might be able to help me.

Hpoe to hear from you,

Best regards, David.

Hi David,

I believe that's difficult to find any recording of her. For so far I know, there are no recordings available today. In the 10 cd-box 'Het Puik van Zoete Kelen', she is represented by one aria (1972) in Gounod's Faust - 'versez vos chagrins dans mon ame' - and there exists a 3 LP set of Bach's St Matthew Passion. Both releases not available any more. But why are you so interested in this soprano? I know something about her, but don't have even a photo of her. Therefore she is on the moment not present at my site.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


24-02-2006
Hi! I'm a big fan of your site, and wanted to ask you a question about some information on the Kathleen Ferrier page.

You list in her discography a -complete- version of Gluck's "Orfeo ed Euridice" she sang at Glyndebourne in England, with the number "AKI 1656-62" attached to it. Can you tell me what this number signifies --
I'm not familiar with the AKI label. I have an abbreviated version of this performance, but have never seen the complete one. I would very much like to hunt this recording down. Please reply when you are able.

Thanks,
Will Chase

Dear Will,

I presume that the AKI label is one of the lesser known labels. I also couldn't find it. But there are more complete recordings of Orfeo with Ferrier, for instance a live-recording from 1951 in Holland. But those live recording are not of the same quality as the abbreviated version you mentioned. I also have this version. For the complete live performance I found this link:

http://www.cduniverse.com/search/xx/music/pid/6731237/a/Collection+Les+Inoub
liables+-+Gluck:+Orfeo+ed+Euridice.htm

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


24-02-2006
The norm for me is to love opera sopranos but after hearing Minnie Ripperton's diction in the song i've fallen in with her voice, and wondering what you think. (after about 2 minutes 25 seconds you here here sing with great diction "here we go") Tho not very strong, diction makes up for it.

Also, why is Yma Sumac group with classical sopanos?

Yma Sumac is of the period of my father and the only singer that could reach such notes those days. If you like it or not isn't so important. Therefore ... one exception for Yma Sumac.
I listened to Minnie Ripperton, but sorry ... not my cup of tea.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


18-02-2006
Bonjour,

Je vous félicite pour la conception de ce site.
Je suis passionnée d'opéra, et ce site m'intéresse beaucoup, mais j'ai un souci au niveau de l'ouverture.

La page du web dans Google indique:
Fernand Faniard - Belgisch heldentenorFernand Faniard, tenor, biografie. ... Chef d'orchestre : Henri Kamm. Mise en scène : Godefroy Landry. Lohengrin (Lohengrin) 1938. ...
www.dutchdivas.net/tenoren/fernand_faniard3.html - 42k - En cache - Pages similaires

Je cherche avant tout des renseignements sur le metteur en scène Godefroy LANDRY, cité dans l'annonce, mais quand j'ouvre ce site, la page que je voudrais visualiser ne dure qu'une seconde pour être affacer par la page des ténors.
Vous est-il possible d'y remédier ?
Sinon, pourriez-vous me fournir des renseignements sur ce Godefroy LANDRY ? Pourrais-je aussi avoir des renseignements sur Andree VALLY ? Pourriez-vous m'indiquer comment faire pour trouver des renseignements sur les metteurs en scène et les artistes lyriques de ces années-là ?

Je vous remercie d'avance pour votre réponse.
Bien sincèrement

Brigitte Godet

Bonjour Brigitte,

I studied French for five years, long, long ago. And it was not the language I was quit familiar with. So I understand only a little bit of your e-mail. However, I changed something in the code of the webpage you mentioned: ..../fernand_faniard3.html. When you now use Google and enter the same link you are redirected to the page Belgische zangers en zangeressen. From there it's easy to find the information you are looking for. Enjoy it.

regards,
Joop Lindeijer


16-02-2006
You obviously know a lot about music. I am an 18 yr old female currently receiving voice training. Do you know how one can expand one's vocal range to cover 5 octaves for example? If you know the answer please would you e-mail me to let me know?

I have a regular voice, nothing spectacular like Mariah Carey or Adam Lopez's voices but I would love to be able to sing in the whistle register because then I could sing in my room to MC's songs!!!

Looking forward to your reply.
Many thanks
Miss Jane Givney

Dear Miss Jane,

I feel very flattered by your thoughts about my knowledge, but unfortunately I cannot help you with singing advises. I do know that it's possible with proper singing lessons to widen ones range, but there must be a certain base. And 5 octaves is much, very much. It's more than a complete choir with the whole range of basses, tenors and sopranos. Such a choir reaches about 4 octaves.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer


15-02-2006

I am an amateur choir singer myself, and have about a year ago quit singing tenor altogether because it was too much strain on the voice, singing alto instead (that sounds crazy at first, but the unfettered falsetto reaches much higher than extending the chest voice with a "head voice"). Since stylistic reasons don't permit my singing alto in modern pieces, I switch between alto and low bass in my choir.
That means that I have to cover three octaves in a typical concert (next weekend, see <URL:http://www.collegium-vocale-bochum.de> for the program), from a bass E (Bruckner) to an alto e (Bach). In contrast to the astonishing feats listed on your page, I have to blend with a choir and have to keep the volume at audible level as well as
controlled. When no carrying power is demanded and the volume is your own choice, getting considerably lower is possible: listen to <URL:http://home.arcor.de/david.kastrup/spancil.mp3>, a folk song rendition I like doing sometimes, mostly for the sake of frustrating "proper" basses. It goes to about G1, quite above the C#1 you claim for the basso profundo on your web page (I have problems hearing anything with a base tone lower than G#1 in that passage, though). On the other end of the range, I am currently being pestered in my lessons with "Che faro senza Euridice" from Gluck's Orfeo, which ends with pretty annoyingly sustained F5 notes. Quite taxing, basically mezzo soprano stuff. So my show-off range, which already adds almost an octave to the actually musically tenable range I employ in the choir, is still short of the more than four octaves claimed for Cristina Deutekom.

Maybe there is some confusion: I often (like in the above example) sing passages that lie two octaves apart to indicate different characters, so I can sing them in three different octaves (of which I don't use the middle octave). Add to that that the melody itself is also close to an octave in range, and you are talking about four octaves. Unfortunately, just talking, not singing. This sort of calculation ends up with one octave too much, an easy mistake to make.

It sounds to me like Cristina Deutekom might have made this sort of mistake when claiming more than four octaves: that's more than an entire choir ever has to cover. You have to go off the chart in your own gender _and_ invade the other gender considerably to manage that feat.

All the best,
David

Dear David,

Thanks for your detailed e-mail. About Cristina's range, there are two possibilities:

1) she cannot count or more likely
2) she meant that her voice goes from a (small octave range) - to f3
(3-striped range), also covering 4 octave ranges. And that's what you can
read on the page!

And, leaving the classical part of the page, a few pop-singers - more competition there - do cover 5 octaves or more. And that's a wider range then a choir with basses .... sopranos, reaching from D to d3 in the graphics.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer


06-01-2006
Dear Joop

Firstly I'd like to congratulate you about your website.It's really intresting and there are many things that I didn't know. As I have to make a project at my school I'd like to ask you if you could send me some samples of whistle singers and especially Georgia Brown becouse my subjcet is "whistle register".

Happy New Year 2006,

Alex

Dear Alex,

If you want to hear Georgia Brown, listen to the samples on her own website.

http://escravosdegeo.sites.uol.com.br/index1.htm

The page is in Portuguese, but you probably find your way.

best regards,
Joop Lindeijer


02-01-2006
Joop!

Hi!

I loved the picture mine that u put talking about me!

Well, my official homepage will be on web this month. Right there will have a page talking about my records and there is a piano that you can click on each key then you can hear each note from G2 to G10, each octave will be available to hear it.

And really some guyz have reason when they say there is no more note is frequency. Yes is a frequency. We got trouble to record my voice singing this high notes cuz the machines that were recording were going crazy and all we heared was noises! It was hard! But we get it!

Sometimes, on my songs I record a note very high and after when I see all I hear is the speakers playing ppsssssszzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!!

God! It's funny!

On the book I got 2 records: World's Greatest Vocal Range G2 to G10 (I reach 9 octaves and I have 8 octaves completed) and Highest Note G10 on GUINNES WORLD RECORDS 2006 on page 172.

Some people have doubt about these records. So, they are questining the credibility of a traditional book that has 50 years of existence?

I made these records to project myself as singer and to promote my name worldwide.

This is not an olympiad, cuz is impossible put one note like G10 in a music.

The notes until C9 the last key possible using an eletronic instrument were measured and above G9 were measured through a frequency analyser.

Thanks for all!

Georgia Brown


 

red arrow Choose English as language/ Kies Nederlands als taal

(p) 2006 Dutch Divas